Publishing a good job ad creates a pleasant problem: a hundred applications to work through. Then reality arrives — two hours of reading, attention fraying, and decisions made on application thirty that bear no resemblance to the ones made on application one. The best candidate is not always cut for lack of skill. They are cut through fatigue, through bias, or because they failed to tick a box that never mattered. Screening fast and screening well is something you organise.
Set the criteria before you open the first application
Screening is won before you read anything. If you define your criteria along the way, you will adjust them unconsciously to justify your preferences.
- List 3 to 5 knockout criteria maximum, and nothing beyond that.
- Keep a hard line between must-have and nice-to-have — the latter must never eliminate anyone.
- Write down what you are trying to prove: a skill, experience of the context, an ability to learn.
A criterion that isn't needed to succeed in the role only shrinks the pile. That is not the same thing.
Screen in two passes, never in one
Reading every file in depth on the first sweep is the surest way to be exhausted a third of the way through. Split it.
- Pass 1, fast: 60 seconds per application, on knockout criteria only. Yes / no / maybe.
- Pass 2, deep: only the "yes" and "maybe" piles, read properly.
- Do the first pass in one block, without mixing it in with interviews.
Two short passes beat one long one: your judgement stays stable from file to file.
Watch the biases that cost you the best candidates
Some screening reflexes dress themselves up as common sense. They eliminate excellent candidates with depressing regularity.
- The career gap: an interruption is not a skills deficit. Ask about it rather than cutting.
- The prestigious school or employer: that is a signal about the past, not about future performance.
- The imperfect CV: weak formatting says nothing about the quality of an engineer, a nurse or a salesperson.
- The contrast effect: an average application looks brilliant right after a bad one. Score against your criteria, not against the previous file.
The real test: could you justify every rejection with a criterion written down in advance? If not, it was bias.
Reply to everyone, including the people you reject
Follow-up is not politeness — it is reputation. Candidates talk to each other, and three weeks of silence costs you applications on the next role you post.
- Track who has been read, shortlisted, rejected — an unread application must never stay invisible.
- Reply to rejected candidates with one honest, brief sentence: no false hope, no humiliating copy-paste.
- Keep the strong candidates you didn't hire: the next role will come round sooner than you think.
In short
Screening a hundred applications means making a hundred decisions with the same rigour. Criteria fixed up front, two distinct passes, vigilance about bias and a reply for everyone: that is what separates recruitment you endure from recruitment you control. Publish your roles and track every application received, read and processed on Portfoler.com.


























































































